Contact: +1 (888) 605-1350
Choosing between Carina Bay Boutique Resort & Casino and Cottages by the Sea? This in-depth comparison breaks down location, vibe, rooms, food, nightlife, price & more so you can decide which resort is the best fit.
Best for adults who want an all-inclusive, beachfront St. Croix stay with pools, on-site activities, and a 21+ casino.
Better for travelers who want a quieter cottage-style beach stay with more independence and a less resort-driven feel.
If you want an adults-only all-inclusive on the secluded East End of St. Croix, Carina Bay Boutique Resort & Casino is the more complete resort choice, with dining, drinks, activities, pools, beach access, and casino entertainment built into the stay.
If your priority is a simpler beachfront cottage atmosphere where the trip feels more self-directed, Cottages by the Sea is the better fit—especially if you do not need an all-inclusive plan or a full resort schedule.
Bottom line: choose Carina Bay Boutique Resort & Casino for an adults-only all-inclusive resort experience; choose Cottages by the Sea for a more independent, low-key cottage stay by the beach.
| Category | Carina Bay Boutique Resort & Casino | Cottages by the Sea |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Vibe | Adults-only all-inclusive beachfront resort on St. Croix’s secluded East End, with a relaxed island pace and built-in resort amenities. | Low-key cottage-style beach stay, better suited to travelers who want independence over a traditional all-inclusive resort setup. |
| Location | Set at Estate Turner Hole near Christiansted on the East End of St. Croix, a quieter and more remote side of the island. | A beach-cottage option on St. Croix, better for guests who want a simpler base for an independent island stay. |
| Rooms & Suites | Resort accommodations aimed at adults, with the convenience of all-inclusive dining, drinks, activities, Wi-Fi, and on-site amenities. | Cottage-style accommodations that feel more residential and independent than a full-service resort room experience. |
| Dining | All-inclusive food and drinks at on-site restaurants and bars, with some specialty items, certain beverages, and casino dining excluded. | Better for travelers comfortable planning meals more independently rather than relying on a resort-wide all-inclusive dining program. |
| Pools & Beach | Two freshwater pools, including one directly on the beach, plus beach activities such as kayaking, snorkeling, paddleboards, and volleyball. | A more cottage-focused beach setting, best if you want a quieter, less programmed beach stay. |
| Kids & Family | Adults-only resort for guests 18+, with no family sections or kids’ amenities; casino entry requires guests to be 21+ with valid ID. | Better for travelers who want a casual cottage stay rather than an adults-only all-inclusive resort environment. |
| Price & Value | Best value for adults who will use the included dining, drinks, pools, activities, beach access, and resort conveniences. | Best value for independent travelers who prefer a cottage-style stay and do not need an all-inclusive resort package. |
Carina Bay Boutique Resort & Casino is built for adults who want the convenience of a resort stay, with all-inclusive food and drinks at on-site venues, complimentary Wi-Fi, and easy access to pools, beach activities, and the casino.
Carina Bay is the better pick if you want a more structured resort experience where dining, drinks, and activities are part of the stay.
Cottages by the Sea is the more independent option, with a cottage-style feel that suits travelers who prefer a simpler beach base over an all-inclusive resort environment.
If you want a quieter, more independent stay without the structure of an all-inclusive plan, Cottages by the Sea is the more natural fit.
Dining at Carina Bay Boutique Resort & Casino is a major advantage if you want meals and drinks organized around the resort. The all-inclusive plan covers food and drinks at on-site restaurants and bars, while some restaurants, special dishes, certain beverages, and casino dining may cost extra.
Expect:
Cottages by the Sea is better for travelers who do not need a resort-run all-inclusive dining plan and are comfortable making meals and drinks a more flexible part of the trip.
If included dining and drinks are important, Carina Bay has the clear edge; if dining freedom matters more, Cottages by the Sea may feel easier.
Carina Bay Boutique Resort & Casino gives guests a true resort-style pool and beach setup, with two freshwater pools, one directly on the beach, plus included activities such as kayaking, snorkeling, paddleboards, tennis, pickleball, and shuffleboard.
Cottages by the Sea is the better fit if your ideal beach stay is simpler and less programmed, with the focus on a relaxed cottage atmosphere rather than a resort pool-and-activity lineup.
If you want pools, included beach activities, and a more complete resort setup, choose Carina Bay; if you want simplicity, Cottages by the Sea is stronger.
Carina Bay Boutique Resort & Casino is an adults-only resort with a minimum guest age of 18, so it is not the right choice for families traveling with children. Its programming and atmosphere are aimed at adult guests.
Cottages by the Sea is the more flexible choice if your group does not fit an adults-only all-inclusive resort model and you prefer a casual, cottage-style stay.
If you need an adults-only escape, Carina Bay is the clear match; if your trip needs a more flexible cottage setup, look to Cottages by the Sea.
Carina Bay Boutique Resort & Casino offers the most value when you will use the all-inclusive food and drinks, pools, beach activities, gym, tennis, pickleball, and on-site entertainment rather than treating the hotel as only a place to sleep.
Cottages by the Sea is the better value if you prefer a more independent stay and do not need the cost or structure of an all-inclusive resort package.
Choose Carina Bay if you want an adults-only, all-inclusive beachfront resort with pools, activities, several dining and bar options, and a 21+ casino on-site.
Cottages by the Sea is the better pick for travelers who want a quieter, more independent cottage-style beach stay without the structure of an all-inclusive resort.
For adults who want resort convenience on St. Croix’s East End, Carina Bay is the stronger choice—especially if included meals, drinks, beach activities, and pools are priorities.
If you would rather keep the trip simple, flexible, and cottage-based, Cottages by the Sea will likely feel like the easier match.
Questions? Contact Us!
Explore more helpful planning guides and insider articles for Carina Bay Boutique Resort & Casino:
