Contact: +1 (888) 605-1350
Choosing between Carina Bay Boutique Resort & Casino and Colony Cove Beach Resort by Antilles Resorts? This in-depth comparison breaks down location, vibe, rooms, food, nightlife, price & more so you can decide which resort is the best fit.
Best for adults who want an all-inclusive St. Croix beach resort with a quieter East End setting, on-site casino, and included activities.
Better for travelers who want a more independent beach-resort stay with condo-style flexibility rather than an adults-only all-inclusive format.
If you want an adults-only, all-inclusive resort experience on St. Croix with restaurants, bars, pools, beach activities, and a 21+ casino on property, Carina Bay Boutique Resort & Casino is the clearer fit.
If your priority is a more self-directed beach stay with the feel of a residential resort rather than a bundled all-inclusive, Colony Cove Beach Resort by Antilles Resorts may be the better match.
Bottom line: choose Carina Bay Boutique Resort & Casino for an adults-only all-inclusive with more built-in resort amenities; choose Colony Cove Beach Resort by Antilles Resorts for a simpler, more independent beach-resort base.
| Category | Carina Bay Boutique Resort & Casino | Colony Cove Beach Resort by Antilles Resorts |
|---|---|---|
| Overall Vibe | Adults-only all-inclusive on St. Croix’s secluded East End, with a beach setting, two freshwater pools, activities, and an on-site 21+ casino. | More independent beach-resort option, better suited to travelers who prefer a less packaged stay over a full all-inclusive resort format. |
| Location | Set at 5025 Estate Turner Hole near Christiansted on the quieter East End of St. Croix, with a remote, away-from-it-all feel. | A St. Croix beach-resort alternative for travelers comparing a more self-contained all-inclusive stay against a more flexible island base. |
| Rooms & Suites | Best for adults who want the simplicity of resort accommodations tied to an all-inclusive plan, with dining, drinks, Wi-Fi, pools, and activities close by. | Better for guests who like the idea of a more residential beach-resort setup and are comfortable planning more of the stay independently. |
| Dining | All-inclusive plan covers food and drinks at on-site restaurants and bars, with venues such as Tuscany Ristorante Italiano, The Wave, Oceans Bar & Grill, East End Coffee, and Latitude Bar. | A better fit if you are not looking for a full all-inclusive dining plan and prefer a more flexible approach to meals during your St. Croix stay. |
| Pools & Beach | Two freshwater pools, including one directly on the beach, plus on-site beach activities such as kayaking, snorkeling, paddleboards, and volleyball. | A beach-resort option for travelers who want coastal access without necessarily choosing the larger all-inclusive amenity bundle. |
| Kids & Family | Adults-only resort for guests 18+, with no family sections or kids’ amenities; the casino is limited to guests 21+ with valid ID. | More appropriate than Carina Bay for travelers who do not need an adults-only resort framework, though specific family programming should be confirmed before booking. |
| Price & Value | Best value for adults who will use the all-inclusive dining, drinks, pools, beach activities, fitness center, and casino access in one resort stay. | Best value for travelers who prefer a less bundled beach-resort stay and do not want to pay primarily for an adults-only all-inclusive experience. |
Rooms at Carina Bay Boutique Resort & Casino make the most sense for adults who want their St. Croix stay centered around a single all-inclusive resort with pools, beach activities, restaurants, bars, and entertainment close at hand.
Carina Bay is the better pick if you want a more complete resort package and do not need a condo-style or self-catering setup.
Colony Cove Beach Resort by Antilles Resorts is the more flexible choice for travelers comparing Carina Bay’s adults-only all-inclusive model against a beach-resort stay that feels more independent.
If you want your accommodations to feel more like a base for exploring and less like a full resort package, Colony Cove Beach Resort by Antilles Resorts is the more natural fit.
Dining at Carina Bay Boutique Resort & Casino is built around the all-inclusive plan, with food and drinks included at on-site restaurants and bars, though some restaurants, special dinners, dishes, beverages, or amenities may carry extra charges.
Expect:
Colony Cove Beach Resort by Antilles Resorts is better viewed as a more independent dining setup when compared with Carina Bay’s all-inclusive format.
If you want meals and drinks folded into the resort experience, Carina Bay has the advantage; if you prefer more flexibility, Colony Cove Beach Resort by Antilles Resorts may suit you better.
Carina Bay Boutique Resort & Casino has a more built-out pool and beach scene, with two freshwater pools, one set directly on the beach, plus included non-motorized water sports.
Colony Cove Beach Resort by Antilles Resorts is the better comparison point for travelers who want a beach-resort setting without choosing Carina Bay’s adults-only, activity-inclusive model.
If you want included beach activities, pools, and a resort hub, Carina Bay is stronger; if you want a quieter base with fewer built-in expectations, Colony Cove Beach Resort by Antilles Resorts is the more flexible choice.
Carina Bay Boutique Resort & Casino is firmly adults-only, with a minimum guest age of 18 and no family sections or kids’ amenities. The on-site casino requires guests to be 21+ with valid ID.
Colony Cove Beach Resort by Antilles Resorts is the more practical option to investigate if your group does not fit an adults-only resort model or wants a less structured beach-resort stay.
If everyone in your party is 18+ and wants all-inclusive ease, Carina Bay is the cleaner fit; if your group needs broader flexibility, look more closely at Colony Cove Beach Resort by Antilles Resorts.
Carina Bay Boutique Resort & Casino offers the most value when you will take advantage of its all-inclusive food and drinks, pools, beach activities, tennis, pickleball, shuffleboard, gym, and on-site casino.
Colony Cove Beach Resort by Antilles Resorts is the better value candidate if you do not need the full all-inclusive structure and would rather keep your St. Croix stay more independent.
Choose Carina Bay if you want an adults-only, all-inclusive St. Croix resort with restaurants, bars, two freshwater pools, included activities, and a 21+ casino on property.
Colony Cove Beach Resort by Antilles Resorts is the better pick if you want a more independent beach-resort stay and do not need the full all-inclusive structure.
For couples and adult groups who want a secluded East End setting, beach activities, and most of the vacation organized around one resort, Carina Bay is the stronger choice.
If you want a simpler St. Croix base with more freedom around dining and daily plans, Colony Cove Beach Resort by Antilles Resorts is likely the more comfortable fit.
Questions? Contact Us!
Explore more helpful planning guides and insider articles for Carina Bay Boutique Resort & Casino:
